Skip to main content

Compare proposals against the same work scope.

This checklist helps property managers, owners’ corporations and consultants organise requirements and comparison points. It is not a price list, liability decision or site-specific work recommendation.

Seven points to check in each proposal.

For each point, note proposal A, proposal B and anything still to be confirmed. Ask the relevant parties to explain differences.

  1. Locations and pipe sections

    Identify buildings, floors, locations, sections and quantities in each proposal, and compare the same scope. Clarify the boundaries and arrangements involving communal or household locations separately.

  2. Materials and fittings

    Check the listed pipework, connections and related materials, including whether specifications and quantities are clear. Similar totals do not establish that materials or scopes are equivalent.

  3. Access and site coordination

    Confirm whether scaffolding, platforms or other access arrangements are needed, who arranges them and whether costs are included. Requirements depend on site conditions.

  4. Other trades and making good

    Identify affected finishes or other installations and the associated arrangements. Record included and excluded work clearly.

  5. Checks and completion information

    Identify the inspections, tests, work photographs and completion information in the proposal, and who needs to confirm handover requirements. Records must reflect the actual work.

  6. Additional work and changes

    Record how extra pipe sections, site findings or proposal changes will be handled. Confirm revised scope, fees and approval arrangements before proceeding with the affected work.

  7. Sequence, coordination and resident impact

    Compare the proposed sequence, coordination needs and communication arrangements. Suitability for phasing, access and supply restoration timing depend on site risks, scope and coordination.

A project brief before assessment

Fill in the information already available and mark unresolved points for confirmation. Agree how photographs and documents will be received separately.

  1. Project information

    Estate or building: ______ Blocks / floors / locations involved: ______

  2. Existing information

    Photos / engineering reports / notices / drawings / current quotations: ______

  3. Scope to discuss

    Repair / replacement / maintenance arrangements / other: ______ Known constraints: ______

  4. People and coordination

    Property manager / owners’ corporation / consultant roles: ______ Access or related work: ______

  5. Points to confirm

    Responsibilities and scope / inclusions and exclusions / phasing / handover requirements: ______

Questions when comparing proposals

  1. Does this checklist determine maintenance liability?

    No. It organises locations, work and comparison information; it does not determine who is responsible or pays. Responsibilities, scope and work allocation require separate confirmation using the applicable information and arrangements.

  2. Can work be carried out in stages?

    Phasing can be discussed following assessment, but suitability depends on site risks, scope and coordination. The existing Hiu Lai Court story describes that project and should not be applied automatically to another estate.

  3. How can maintenance arrangements be compared with one-off work?

    Compare the contract term, pipework covered, inclusions, exclusions, fee calculation and exceptions separately. Refund, warranty and other arrangements must follow the individual written proposal and contract, rather than a promotional summary.

Give the discussion a shared basis

Gather the checklist with existing notices, reports and drawings. Refer to the existing contract stories for project experience, then discuss assessment and proposals for your estate. A published case is not a promise for another estate.

Use this checklist to prepare an enquiry. Scope, feasibility, arrangements and fees depend on a site assessment and written proposal.